It’s easy to get confused with all the car insurance myths floating around. Some believe, "The cheapest is best," while others think, "I don’t need insurance; I’m a great driver." Let's clear things up. In this blog, we’ll debunk some of the most common car insurance myths so you can make smarter decisions.
1. What does car insurance actually cover?
Fiction: “Car insurance only covers damage to my car.”
Fact: Car insurance covers much more, as discussed in our guide. In New Zealand, a comprehensive car insurance policy can include theft, damage to other vehicles, legal liability, windscreen replacement, and even roadside assistance. Some policies also cover lost keys and children's car seats. According to the Quashed Index, the average cost of car insurance has been increasing, so it’s essential to know exactly what you’re paying for.
What you need to know: Not all policies are the same. With Quashed, you can easily compare policies and see if extras like trailer cover or rental car hire are included. Always read the fine print to avoid surprises when you need to make a claim.
2. What’s the best car insurance?
Fiction: “All car insurance is the same—just pick the cheapest one.”
Fact: The best car insurance depends on your needs. Do you only need basic third-party cover, or do you want full windscreen replacement and rental car cover? There’s no one-size-fits-all solution. If you drive a newer car, comprehensive cover might be your best bet to avoid costly repairs.
What you need to know: Don’t just choose based on price. Consider what kind of protection is important to you. A cheaper policy might save you money now but leave you exposed later. To avoid costly mistakes, check out our blog on the Ten Insurance Mistakes That Cost You Money.
3. Why is car insurance important?
Fiction: “I don’t need insurance; I’m a safe driver.”
Fact: Even if you’re a safe driver, accidents happen. More importantly, liability cover is essential in New Zealand. Without insurance, you could face huge costs if you’re found at fault in an accident, not to mention potential legal fees. Insurance doesn’t just protect your car—it protects you financially if something goes wrong. The type of vehicle you drive can impact your insurance needs—especially if you drive newer models, like electric vehicles
What you need to know: Liability cover is a must-have, as it protects you from the financial consequences of accidents. Always ensure your policy includes liability protection to safeguard against unexpected legal or repair costs.
4. Is car insurance too complicated to understand?
Fiction: “Car insurance is too complicated to understand.”
Fact: It’s not as confusing as it seems. Essentially, you pay a premium (monthly or annually), and in return, your insurer covers certain costs if something happens to your car. The key is knowing what’s included in your policy and what your excess is when making a claim. That’s where Quashed comes in handy—it helps you compare policies easily, so you know exactly what you’re paying for and what’s covered.
What you need to know: The basics are straightforward—just make sure you understand the policy terms, your excess, and what’s included in the cover. Tools like Quashed make this comparison even easier.
5. Which car insurance is cheapest?
Fiction: “Always go for the cheapest policy.”
Fact: The cheapest option isn’t always the best one. While it’s tempting to save a few bucks upfront, a cheaper policy may leave you exposed when it’s time to make a claim. Coverage is key—saving now might cost you later if your policy doesn’t include features like theft protection or roadside assistance.
What you need to know: Look beyond price when choosing a policy. Think about what protection you’ll need in real-life situations, such as accidents, theft, or breakdowns. Balancing cost with coverage ensures you’re not caught out when the unexpected happens.
6. How are car insurance premiums calculated?
Fiction: “Insurance premiums are just pulled out of thin air.”
Fact: Insurers calculate premiums based on several factors, including your age, driving history, the type of car you drive, where you live, and how often you drive. Younger drivers tend to pay more, as they’re statistically more likely to be involved in accidents. According to the Quashed Index, comprehensive car insurance for drivers aged 18–24 costs $1,711 annually on average.
What you need to know: Your car’s value and your location also play a big role. If you drive a high-value car or live in a high-risk area (think Auckland storms), expect your premiums to be higher.
The average Kiwi household can save
$2,023.79 a year by shopping their insurance!
Find out how your renewal prices stack up against other options out there!
7. Why is car insurance so expensive?
Fiction: “Insurance companies are just out to get me.”
Fact: Premiums are rising, but for good reasons. According to the Quashed Index, comprehensive car insurance premiums have increased by 18.1% in the last year, driven by factors such as inflation, higher repair costs, and environmental events like flooding. For younger drivers (aged 18-24), premiums have skyrocketed by 58% in two years, making it even more important to shop smart.
What you need to know: While costs are up, that doesn’t mean you should settle for an overpriced policy. Check out our guide, Smart Ways to Slash Your Car Insurance, to see how you might manage costs.
8. What car insurance should I get?
Fiction: “I’m a great driver; I don’t need much insurance.”
Fact: Even the best drivers can end up in accidents, and sometimes it’s not even your fault. The type of insurance you need depends on your driving habits. Comprehensive car insurance covers damage to your car and others', while third-party insurance might be enough if you drive an older car and only want to cover damage to other vehicles.
What you need to know: Assess your car’s value, how often you drive, and your risk tolerance. Comprehensive car insurance offers peace of mind, but third-party might be all you need if your car is older and low-value.
9. Can you cancel car insurance anytime?
Fiction: “Once I buy car insurance, I’m stuck with it for a year.”
Fact: Most car insurance policies in New Zealand allow you to cancel at any time, but it’s important to check your insurer’s terms. While you might receive a refund for any unused portion of your premium, some providers may charge a cancellation fee. If you find a better deal or your circumstances change, switching policies is often easier than you think.
What you need to know: Always review your policy's cancellation terms before making any decisions.
10. Do comprehensive car insurance policies cover everything?
Fiction: “Comprehensive car insurance means I’m covered for anything and everything.”
Fact: While comprehensive car insurance provides the broadest coverage, it doesn’t cover everything. For example, general wear and tear, mechanical breakdowns, and illegal modifications are often excluded. That’s why it’s crucial to read the fine print and know exactly what’s included in your policy.
What you need to know: Comprehensive car insurance policies can still have exclusions, so don’t assume you’re covered for all scenarios. Use Quashed to compare policies and find out which ones offer the best protection for your specific needs.
Shop smarter with Quashed
Insurance just got way easier with Quashed. Compare, shop and track all your insurance in one place.
How Quashed can help you cut through the myths
Car insurance doesn’t have to be confusing. Quashed clears up the myths with real-time comparisons, so you can see exactly what’s covered and find the right fit:
Debunk the confusion with real-time quotes: Compare quotes from leading insurers side by side in real-time, so you can easily see what each policy covers—say goodbye to hours spent on endless online research.
Tailored to your needs, not the myths: Quashed helps you find a policy that’s customised to your car, driving habits, and budget—without any myths holding you back.
Save time and money: Forget the myths that say shopping for car insurance is time-consuming or confusing. With Quashed, you’ll get accurate, side-by-side comparisons in minutes, helping you make smarter, faster decisions.
We believe car insurance should be:
Simple, not complicated
Transparent, not confusing
Personalized, not generic
Quick, not time-consuming
Start comparing now and discover a smarter way to find the right car insurance. Join over 45,000 Kiwis today and get the coverage you need in minutes.
FAQs
What’s the difference between comprehensive and third-party insurance?
Comprehensive car insurance covers both your car and others’ in case of damage, while third-party insurance typically only covers damages you cause to other vehicles. Simple as that!
How are car insurance premiums calculated in New Zealand?
Premiums are determined based on several factors, including your age, driving history, the make and model of your car, and your location. For example, younger drivers often pay higher premiums due to the increased risk of accidents. Keep in mind that everyone’s situation is different.
Does cheaper car insurance mean I’m saving money?
Not necessarily. While a lower premium might look attractive, it may lack important covers like theft protection or roadside assistance. Balancing cost and cover ensures you’re protected when the unexpected happens. Want more info? Check out our blog on key considerations with car insurance.
Is it true that car insurance doesn’t cover modifications?
Yes, certain modifications, especially performance enhancements like turbochargers, can make your car uninsurable or raise your premiums. Check your policy’s terms to know which modifications are covered.
Can I cancel my car insurance policy anytime?
Yes, most insurers in New Zealand allow you to cancel your policy at any time, but some may charge a cancellation fee. Be sure to check your policy terms or get in touch with your insurer if you’re thinking of making a change.
Why should I compare car insurance quotes?
Comparing car insurance quotes is crucial because it helps you find the right balance between affordable premiums and solid coverage. For tips on how to compare quotes and what to look out for, check out our blog.
What should I consider when renewing my car insurance?
Before you hit the renew button, take a moment to review your policy. Ensure it still fits your needs and reflects any changes in your car's value or your circumstances. Is your coverage still up-to-date? If you’re not sure, check out our blog on Sorting Out Your Car Insurance Renewal for some helpful tips.
Market Scan quotes are direct from insurers
So you won’t pay more with Quashed
